Flex appeal: Kia Venga vs Ford B-MAX & Nissan Note

If you’re after a practical yet compact car, you don’t have to stick to the age-old supermini formula. There’s a big group of vehicles that mix MPV versatility with a compact hatchback footprint, and the latest to offer this blend of interior space in a squashed-down body is the facelifted Kia Venga.

24

While it might not be instantly obvious, Kia has tweaked its supermini-MPV for 2015 to keep it looking fresh, while adding some more luxurious touches inside. At £13,895, the Venga has price on its side – but it has to face tough competition, as there’s a legion of cars out there offering a similar level of practicality with more efficient engines and even more tech.

24

In a competitive sector where flexibility rules, price alone is not enough, which is why we’ve lined up two of the class leaders – the cleverly packaged Ford B-MAX and the Nissan Note with its surprisingly spacious interior – to see if the Kia is good enough to come out on top despite a relatively inefficient, old-school engine.

24

Both rivals are more expensive than the Venga, but do the Ford and Nissan’s extra features mean they’re worth the money?

• Kia Venga review

Used - available now

2018 BMW

3 Series

43,000 milesAutomaticDiesel2.0L

Cash £15,500

View 3 Series

2019 BMW

1 Series

50,100 milesManualDiesel1.5L

Cash £10,500

View 1 Series

2018 Mercedes

A-Class

59,250 milesAutomaticPetrol1.6L

Cash £14,100

View A-Class

2018 Volkswagen

Polo

41,933 milesManualPetrol1.2L

Cash £10,400

View Polo

• Ford B-MAX review

• Nissan Note review

Click the links above to read individual reviews, and scroll down to find out which car wins...

Head-to-head

Versatility

24

All three of our test cars feature variable height floors, concealed compartments and sliding rear benches, so it has to be a special feature to crown one of these cars the most versatile. Even though the Note and Venga are roomier inside, the B-MAX has a couple more strings to its bow in the shape of those sliding doors and the folding front seat.

Ease of access

24

Access to the B-MAX’s rear is easy with those sliding doors and no central pillar. The Kia also lets you jump in with zero fuss due to its high-up seating position. The Note isn’t as simple – you have to lower yourself into the deeper seats. Despite more legroom, you feel hemmed in.

Technology

24

Cheap doesn’t always mean cheerful – on the Kia and Ford, equipment is sparse. Even in a small car, the Note’s reversing camera and other gadgets are welcome. Sat-nav and a big touchscreen infotainment unit could be a deal-maker for some.

Verdict

1st place: Nissan Note

24

Lower running costs, more equipment and competitive practicality see the Nissan Note take the victory. Its 1.2 engine isn’t fast, but it does the job sufficiently, while it’s refined enough for town and motorway driving. The Note’s strength, however, is its packaging and versatility, with a roomy cabin and boot that offer more space for passengers and luggage than either supermini-MPV rival.

2nd place: Ford B-MAX

24

If you’re after a drivers’ car with a sensible side, then the B-MAX is your best bet. Its perky engine and Fiesta-based chassis are the most fun, but they’re not enough to top this test. It’s too expensive in this company, the dash design is confusing and the Ford isn’t practical enough, either – although its party piece doors will make family life and loading the cabin extremely easy.

3rd place: Kia Venga

24

If the Venga’s engine was cleaner and more willing, it’d be a different story, as the roomy, comfy and refined Kia would be more appealing. But even at this ‘2’ version’s budget price point, you can’t get away from the high CO2 output and dearth of interior tech. The extremely mild facelift means the Venga just doesn’t feel like a new car, but one that’s stuck in the last decade.

Other options for similar money…

New: Skoda Fabia Estate SE 1.2 TSI 90

Price: £14,595 Engine: 1.2-litre 4cyl, 89bhp

Skoda’s Fabia Estate is hugely practical, boasting a 530-litre boot. SE trim doesn’t bring much standard kit – like our ‘2’-spec Kia – but 15-inch alloys, air-con, DAB and Bluetooth are all on the equipment list. 

Used: MINI Cooper Clubman

Price: £14,500 Engine: 1.6-litre 4cyl, 122bhp

If you want petrol power, but fancy something with more of a premium feel, a used MINI Clubman is within budget. Its 260-litre boot means it’s down on practicality, but £14,500 gets you a low-mile Cooper with cruise control, part-leather seats and sat-nav.

Key specs: