Ford Mondeo ST TDCi vs Octavia vRS
Hot diesels from Skoda and Ford are bargains right now. Which is our choice?
Switching to diesel power to reduce your fuel bills doesn’t mean you have to compromise on performance – as the Ford Mondeo ST TDCi and Skoda Octavia vRS TDI 170 prove.
Over the years, Auto Express has heaped praise on both cars in standard guise. And these frugal but punchy top-of-the-range variants offer the same practicality in a much more entertaining package. Adding
to the appeal for second-hand buyers is the fact that depreciation hasn’t been kind to either model. Both have lost a great deal of money since new, so they now represent excellent value.
Fitted with the VW Group’s 168bhp turbodiesel unit, the Octavia is the more potent car, with a healthy 15bhp advantage over the Mondeo. And while its tuned powerplant isn’t as refined and smooth as many modern oil-burning engines, it’s got grunt by the bucketload, which means overtaking is a breeze.
The vRS sits 12mm lower than the standard Octavia, and comes with 17 or 18-inch alloy wheels, so the ride is a little on the firm side. But it handles with nimble precision and the steering is responsive. What’s more, the interior provides masses of space. The boot can swallow an enormous 560 litres of luggage, while passengers in the rear have plenty of room.
Used - available now
2024 Skoda
Octavia
52,090 milesAutomaticDiesel2.0L
Cash £16,800
2021 Skoda
Octavia
56,105 milesAutomaticPetrol1.0L
Cash £13,100
2018 Skoda
Octavia
45,508 milesAutomaticDiesel1.6L
Cash £11,697
2024 Skoda
Octavia
15,799 milesAutomaticPetrol1.5L
Cash £18,200Although the Skoda costs more to buy, stronger residuals make it a much safer place for your money. Don’t discount the Mondeo, however. It’s just as capable, and the low price tag is very tempting – especially considering it would have set you back £4,625 more than the Octavia new.
The longer wheelbase of the Ford means extra room in the rear, while sporty styling is carried over from the petrol version of the ST – you get 18-inch alloy wheels and a bodykit as standard. Find a post-2005 facelifted model, and it will look even fresher.
The Mondeo has a 230cc advantage in engine capacity, and this translates into more torque: 400Nm from 1,800rpm. The potent oil-burner also helps the Ford strike a great balance between performance and cruising refinement. So although it’s not quite as quick as the Skoda, it makes a better all-round proposition.
And that’s the key. The Ford is great to drive, more spacious and better value than its Czech rival, and so has to be our choice.
Extra Info
Skoda Octavia vRS TDI
2006 to date
Engine: 2.0-litre 4cyl
Power: 168bhp
0-60mph: 7.5 seconds
Insurance group: 14
Economy: 46.3mpg
CO2: 157g/km
Prices: From £9,000
Why? Raucous turbocharged engine, sharp handling and much stronger residuals than the Ford. It’s more powerful and faster, too – although this comes at a price.
Ford Mondeo ST TDCi
2005-2007
Engine: 2.2-litre 4cyl
Power: 153bhp
0-62mph: 8.7 seconds
Insurance group: 13
Economy: 48.7mpg
CO2: 161g/km
Prices: From £6,000
Why? Better all-rounder of the pair. Not only is the Mondeo significantly cheaper, it offers a more tempting blend of practicality and driving appeal than the Czech contender.
