Kia Picanto vs Renault Twingo & Hyundai i10

In a world of giant cities, tiny city cars are becoming more appropriate. As urban roads clog up, downsizing to smaller models can help make driving in town easier, with modest dimensions allowing easy progress through congested streets and making parking simpler.

• Best city cars

23

There’s no shortage of cars vying for your hard-earned cash, either, and the latest to hit the market is Kia’s facelifted Picanto. It’s a mild update on the affordable, head-turning urban runaround with an even more efficient engine to help cut running costs further – but it’s got a tough challenge to face.

23

We’ve lined up the mature Hyundai i10, which is practical enough to shame models in the class above, as well as the Renault Twingo, with its fresh, leftfield approach to the conventional city car recipe. Has the new Picanto got the beating of them?

23

All of these contenders come in under the magic £10,000 mark, so are cheap to buy and economical to run. Yet which of our trio of pocket-sized runabouts is king of the urban jungle? We took to the road to find out.

• Kia Picanto review

• Renault Twingo review

• Hyundai i10 review

Used - available now

2020 KIA

Picanto

22,480 milesManualPetrol1.0L

Cash £10,999

View Picanto

2019 KIA

Picanto

38,047 milesManualPetrol1.0L

Cash £7,899

View Picanto

2015 KIA

Picanto

26,440 milesAutomaticPetrol1.2L

Cash £8,999

View Picanto

2023 KIA

Picanto

6,863 milesManualPetrol1.0L

Cash £12,749

View Picanto

Click the links above to read individual reviews, and scroll down to see which city car takes top honours in this test...

Head-to-head

Styling

23

The city car class is bursting with quality, so to stand out, looks matter. The Twingo fits the bill, with a cute but funky design and plenty of personalisation – including our car’s peel-back roof (above). The new Picanto isn’t radically different, but its sharp lines still appear fresh. In this company, the dowdy i10 isn’t going to win any prizes for style.

Turning circle

23

It might not be able to park nose to the kerb like an original Smart car, but the Twingo’s incredible manoeuvrability means it’s right at home in the city. With so much steering lock, tight spaces are simple, while three-point turns become two. It makes the others look like stretched limos.

Boot space

23

Both the i10 and Twingo have bigger boots than a Suzuki Swift, so downsizing to a city car doesn’t have to mean a loss of practicality. The Hyundai carries four people and luggage with ease, but in the Twingo and Picanto, you have to travel light.

Verdict

1st place: Hyundai i10

23

We can’t help but be impressed by how well developed the i10 feels for such a small car. It offers bags of practicality and is a decent cruiser, plus its cabin delivers big car quality and refinement. It can’t match the Twingo for outright fun, but its broad spread of abilities makes the little Hyundai hard to ignore and it takes a well deserved victory in this test.

2nd place: Renault Twingo

23

In town, the Renault’s darty handling and superb manoeuvrability are hard to ignore. Add to that its fun looks, fair spec and surprising versatility given its size, and the Twingo has lots going for it. Yet its engine is short on power, and it struggles on longer journeys. Yes, it’s fun and funky, but the Twingo’s appeal is a little uneven and it can’t match the i10 for all-round appeal.

3rd place: Kia Picanto

23

The Picanto is by no means a bad city car, but this facelift is so minimal that it hasn’t really changed our verdict. This three-door model can’t compete against the practicality an extra pair of doors adds, either, although the SR7’s standard kit list is good. In this guise, the Picanto represents a middle ground between the town-friendly Twingo and relaxed i10.

Other options in this category

Skoda Citigo SE 5dr

Price: £9,420 Engine: 1.0-litre 3cyl, 59bhp

Skoda’s Citigo combines all of the best elements of the three cars above – with five doors and a roomy, classy cabin, there’s lots of practicality and a bit of panache. It might be slightly down on power, but the SE is well priced and equipped.

Toyota Aygo x-play

Price: £10,295 Engine: 1.0-litre 3cyl, 68bhp

It’s a little more expensive, but the new Toyota Aygo is one of the most customisable city cars of the moment. You can choose different colours for the striking ‘x’ face, and with five doors there’s still lots of functionality on offer.

Key specs: