Ford Mustang vs Nissan 370Z

It looks as if Ford is on to a winner with its Mustang. Dealers are struggling to keep pace with demand, and our drives of the UK-spec right-hand-drive model have shown that the bulging order books are entirely justified.

However, the big question still to be answered is whether it makes as much sense with forced induction and half as many cylinders. Purists may feel that fitting a 2.3-litre turbo EcoBoost engine in a car as down-home American as the Mustang is sacrilege, but on the other hand, it delivers nearly as much pace as the V8 and offers greater efficiency.

• Best sports cars

To see how the EcoBoost model fits in, we’ve lined up a stalwart of the coupe class in the form of the Nissan 370Z. While it has only two seats compared to the Mustang’s four, it’s similarly priced, power comes from a 3.7-litre naturally aspirated V6 and, just like the Ford, promises to deliver rear-wheel-drive thrills.

24

We headed for some great driving roads to find out if the Mustang is still a winner in efficient EcoBoost guise.

Head-to-head

Performance

At the track, the more powerful Nissan was faster in the sprint from 0-60mph, but the torquier Ford delivers a broader spread of power for overtaking.

Used - available now

2020 Ford

Mustang

63,000 milesManualPetrol2.3L

Cash £25,795

View Mustang

2022 Ford

Mustang

27,016 milesManualPetrol5.0L

Cash £36,700

View Mustang

2017 Ford

Mustang

86,220 milesAutomaticPetrol2.3L

Cash £19,395

View Mustang

2022 Ford

Mustang

5,332 milesAutomaticPetrol5.0L

Cash £49,926

View Mustang

In corners, both models feel agile and grippy, although the EcoBoost steals a march with its more composed ride and sharper steering, giving drivers more confidence when pressing on. 

24

Badge history

The Mustang can trace its roots back to 1964, and the 370Z’s lineage started in 1969 with the Datsun 240Z. Both are now into their sixth generations, but while the Ford has been in continuous production, Nissan’s Z cars took a break from 1997-2002 between the 300ZX and 350Z.

Turbo first?

The EcoBoost isn’t the first turbo Mustang to be sold in the UK. Ford shipped the 2.3 Turbo Ghia here as a special import in 1979 and converted it to right-hand drive. Not many were sold, though, as it was slower and more expensive than the Capri. 

Verdict

First place: Ford Mustang

24

The Mustang wins as it offers decent handling, reasonable running costs and better everyday usability than the 370Z. However, it’s not without its faults. Standard kit is good but quality isn’t up to scratch, and the engine lacks character. If you can afford £4,000 extra, we’d choose the V8 every time; if you can’t stomach its running costs, the EcoBoost is a fast and fun alternative.

Second place: Nissan 370Z

24

While the 370Z had old-school charm when it was launched, seven years on it just feels dated. The V6 performs well, but it sounds unpleasantly strained and harsh when extended. And although the rear-drive handling is entertaining, the Ford is just as good and far more comfortable when you’re taking it easy. Factor in the higher price and running costs, and the Nissan loses.

Other options in this category

New: BMW 228i M Sport

Price: £29,750Engine: 2.0-litre 4cyl, 245bhp

There are few rear-drive coupes at this price, but the BMW 228i closely matches the Mustang. It does 0-62mph in 5.8 seconds and handles well. It has less kit, but cabin quality is well ahead of the Ford’s.

Used: Ford Mustang Fastback (Mk1)

Price: £30,000Engine: 4.7-litre V8, 271bhp

You could have a classic Mustang with the famous 289ci Windsor V8 for a similar price to the EcoBoost. It’ll cost more to run, and finding an unmodified car will be hard, but you’ll likely be able to sell it for as much as you bought it once you’re done.

Figures