Volkswagen Passat GTE vs BMW 330e

The aftermath of the emissions scandal means 2016 hasn’t been great for VW. Yet none of its new cars is directly affected, and the brand is developing alternative power sources to put it back on track in delivering low emissions. As well as efficient petrols and diesels, there are up! and Golf EVs, while the Golf GTE is a plug-in hybrid.

• All the latest on VW's 'dieselgate' scandal

Latest to join the line-up is the Passat GTE, which uses the same 1.4 TSI petrol engine and electric drive. More power and 39g/km emissions make it a tempting company car choice, while it comes as a saloon or estate. Its plug-in hybrid rival from BMW, the 49g/km 330e, has a similar petrol-electric drivetrain. Rather than being marked out as a separate model, it comes in the same trims as the rest of the 3 Series range. The VW starts from £36,525, the 330e £33,935; can the Passat GTE justify its higher price by delivering a more convincing hybrid driving experience?

Head to head

Charging

46

VW has put the Passat’s socket in the nose, so it’s easy to plug in when you’re parked in a multi-storey bay. The BMW’s socket is on the nearside front wing, so it can be trickier to route the cable.

Used - available now

2020 Mazda

MX-30

38,534 milesAutomaticElectric

Cash £9,999

View MX-30

2023 BMW

5 Series

29,622 milesAutomaticPetrol2.0L

Cash £25,499

View 5 Series

2023 Nissan

Juke

11,933 milesAutomaticPetrol1.0L

Cash £16,399

View Juke

2024 Vauxhall

Grandland

28,913 milesAutomaticPetrol1.2L

Cash £18,999

View Grandland

Both cars have an internal fuel flap release. This ensures the plug and tank flaps aren’t open at the same time, reducing the risk of fires from petrol vapour.

Drive system

The Passat’s 1.4TSI engine is to the left of the engine bay, while bright orange cables form part of the hybrid system to the right. There’s a tidier layout under the 330e’s bonnet, as the car’s electric drive system is tucked behind the longitudinal four-cylinder engine with the gearbox.

Plug-in Car Grant

46

Private buyers can still use the government scheme, but a restructure means hybrids only get a £2,500 contribution.

However, even with this discount the basic GTE is still £3k more than a Passat R Line with 187bhp 2.0 TDI and DSG box.

Results

First place: Volkswagen Passat GTE

46

It’s a narrow victory for the Passat GTE, thanks to VW’s more effective hybrid system. You can use it in pure electric mode more often than the BMW, and it’s more flexible. The car is also more practical, plus there’s more kit. However, as with all plug-ins, ask yourself whether the VW fits your lifestyle before taking the plunge. If you do a lot of long journeys, the diesel Passat is still a better bet.

Second place: BMW 330e

46

The 330e’s hybrid system is good, and its emphasis on performance makes it a top choice for keen and green drivers. It also handles nearly as sharply as a normal 3 Series, while the low-key eco looks will appeal to many. It’s slightly cheaper for both private and business users, too. However, it’s less practical than the VW and its hybrid system isn’t as versatile, plus efficiency takes a hit. 

Also consider...

Mercedes C 350e

Price: £38,899

Engine: 2.0-litre 4cyl hybrid, 293bhp

The C 350e has 48g/km emissions, but splits these two on price, while Mercedes says it can sprint from 0-62mph in less than six seconds. Like the Passat, it's also offered as an estate, although it won't be as practical as VW's load-lugger.

Volvo V60 D5 Twin Engine

Price: £38,105

Engine: 2.4-litre 5cyl hybrid, 227bhp

It was a pioneer of the plug-in hybrid formula in this sector, and Volvo has just launched a new entry-level V60. It features four-wheel drive, but the boot is small for an estate, and the diesel engine is thirsty if you're relying on it alone.

Facts and figures