Kia Sportage vs Jeep Compass: family SUV hybrids face-off

These are strange times for Jeep. The firm has long been considered the US alternative to Land Rover for off-road enthusiasts, but with the Wrangler now off the price lists, there’s no dedicated 4x4 in the company’s line-up. In fact, it currently offers just two models; the petite Avenger and the car we’re testing here, the Compass family SUV.

Four-wheel drive is available on both, but neither is going to match the Wrangler for off-road prowess, and the focus is a lot more on rugged style and everyday usability.

Just like the Avenger, the Compass comes in electric, PHEV and hybrid guises, and it’s the latter we’re testing here. But the compact family SUV class is a hard-fought part of the market, so the Compass is going to have to be pretty impressive to make an impact.

To find out how good it is, we’ve lined up a strong seller in the sector in the shape of the Kia Sportage. The fifth-generation model was given a facelift at the end of last year, while the special edition Storm model tested here offers extra kit at a value-driven price. There’s no electric car to choose from (the Kia EV5 covers that base), but as with the Compass, there are PHEV and hybrid powertrains, plus a mild-hybrid petrol version.

Used - available now

2023 Volkswagen

T-Cross

13,133 milesManualPetrol1.0L

Cash £16,897

View T-Cross

2024 Volkswagen

Tiguan

27,683 milesManualPetrol1.5L

Cash £16,797

View Tiguan

2018 Mercedes

A-Class

44,265 milesAutomaticDiesel2.1L

Cash £11,990

View A-Class

2020 BMW

4 Series

79,614 milesAutomaticDiesel2.0L

Cash £12,990

View 4 Series

Did you know you can sell your car through Auto Express? We’ll help you get a great price and find a great deal on a new car, too.

Jeep Compass

26

Previous versions of the Compass have shared platforms with other models (the Mk1 was also a Mitsubishi ASX, while the Mk2 was a Fiat 500X) and the third generation is based on the Stellantis Group’s STLA platform, as used by the Peugeot 3008 and many others.

That means there are petrol, hybrid and EV powertrains on offer, while Jeep adds rugged looks to the mix. Prices start at just under £35,000, rising to nearly £48,000.

Tester’s notes

Just like the Avenger, the Compass features plenty of design ‘Easter Eggs’ that reference the company’s roots. The bottom edge of the windscreen has a silhouette of the Compass camping, while the Great Bear constellation features just beneath the rear-view mirror, although it looks more like some stubborn road grime that has hit the screen.

The original Jeep features on the centre caps of the wheels, while the seven-bar grille motif appears on the corner of the front bumper and on top of the dashboard.

Jeep has taken a leaf out of Peugeot’s book and offers the Compass in the best colour as standard. Hawaii Green really stands out on the road, while the other metallic shades, including the Pacific Blue of our test car, Yosemite Silver, Vulcano Black, Antarctica White and Amazonia Green – which has echoes the olive drab of the original Willys Jeep – cost £800 extra, but look rather dull.

The Compass price list states that adding a contrast black roof costs £1,200, even if it’s combined with the standard Hawaii hue.

Latest Jeep Compass deals

Kia Sportage

26

The Sportage has been a staple of the Kia line-up for more than 30 years, although it was the third generation that arrived in 2010 which really launched it as a stylish SUV, and sales rocketed as a result. 

We’re now on to the fifth generation, but the basic formula of the Mk3 remains, with sharp looks, plenty of useful space and neat touches throughout the cabin. Prices start from £31,400, with the highest-spec PHEV with four-wheel drive at £48k.

Tester’s notes

Adjustable regenerative braking is often the reserve of fully electric models, but Kia, as with Jeep and other Stellantis brands, has seen fit to include it on the Sportage. And just like Kia’s EVs, it’s super-easy to adjust the set-up on the fly, because you use the paddles located behind the steering wheel. 

There are three levels of strength, ranging from heavy resistance to freewheeling, and it offers a good opportunity to recharge the drive battery when descending a steep slope, for example.

Storm special edition is a trim level that offers added value to the Sportage and the all-electric EV5. Metallic paint is standard in grey, dark grey or black, while the black interior adds artificial leather seats with suede-effect upper sections. The front seats have electric adjustment and are ventilated as well as heated, while the outer rear seats are heated. 

An eight-speaker Harman Kardon sound system is added, as are unique 18-inch alloy wheels and customisable ambient lighting on the automatic models.

Latest Kia Sportage deals

Head-to-head

26

On the road

The Jeep is less powerful than the Kia, so it’s slower from 0-62mph by almost 2.5 seconds, but good mid-range torque means it doesn’t tend to feel sluggish. The gearbox doesn’t like to be rushed, though.

The Sportage feels more grown-up than the Compass, with neutral handling and a comfortable ride. An unsettled low-speed ride spoils the Jeep’s all-round ability, but it improves at higher speeds.

Tech highlights

Component sharing is obvious in both models, with the Jeep featuring the same touchscreen software as other Stellantis products. At least the Compass has a rotary drive selector instead of the toggle switch found in numerous other models.

While the Kia has a smaller touchscreen, the software it runs is more user-friendly, with a menu system that’s long-winded, but easier to navigate.

Price and running

Within the realms of the Stellantis line-up, the Compass costs less than the Peugeot 3008, but is undercut by both the Vauxhall Grandland and Citroen C5 Aircross.

The Sportage is cheaper than the Jeep at the low end of the range, although the highest-spec four-wheel-drive PHEV matches a top-spec Compass EV. Kia’s hybrid system offers fuel saving benefits over the system found in the Jeep.

Practicality

While the Compass is a bigger car than the Sportage, the Kia is better packaged and has more interior space overall. The back seats are wider and there’s a greater range of legroom in the rear, while the boot is more than 100 litres larger, at 587 litres.

The Jeep includes some neat touches. There’s enough under-floor storage if you want to add a spare wheel, while the seats and rubber mats will be easy to clean.

Safety

The Jeep has a four-star Euro NCAP rating to the Sportage’s five, but the two scores can’t be compared because of the constant updating of the organisation’s tests.

Silencing the speed limit warning in the Kia is simple, via a long press of the volume control. In the Jeep, you can access a menu via the shortcut button below the touchscreen. A head-up display is offered on the Compass as part of a £1,500 pack.

Ownership

Jeep’s three-year/60,000-mile warranty is backed up by roadside assistance for the same period, but Kia’s seven years of cover is more attractive for long-term buyers.

However, Jeep owners are a relatively happy bunch when compared with Kia buyers. In our Driver Power ownership survey, the US firm’s cars earned it eighth place out of 30 manufacturers, compared with 25th for the Korean company.

Verdict

Winner: Kia Sportage

26

The Sportage takes victory here thanks to its spacious interior and efficient hybrid powertrain. It’s a car that offers dependability without throwing up any surprises; it simply gets on with the job of being family transport, and it feels as if it will put up with the kind of abuse that this is likely to endure.

It’s not particularly exciting to drive, while the infotainment is now starting to feel a bit dated, but this Storm special edition offers a lot of kit for the money, and should offer plenty of trouble-free miles of driving.

Runner up: Jeep Compass

26

Jeep has done a good job of differentiating the Compass from the number of other Stellantis models that share the same platform by injecting some rugged charm into its contender. The chunky looks are appealing, while the cabin design offers a different take on upmarket quality by adding some of Jeep’s trademark practicality to the mix.

The hybrid powertrain isn’t the best performer or most efficient, while the low-speed ride could be better, but the Compass is a good pick if you want to stand out.

Prices and specs

What we would choose

26

Jeep Compass

We’d stick with the standard Hawaii Green paint because it’s the brightest, while the £1,500 ADAS package with head-up display, active lane-change assist, predictive cruise control and rear cross-traffic alert is good value.

Kia Sportage

Storm edition versions of the Sportage don’t have any options to choose from, so the only thing you need to do is pick a no-cost colour. Looking at the spec list, you’re not really left wanting for equipment, anyway.

Looking for your next car? You can now search our nationwide dealer network for a choice of great cars on offer right now with new, used and leasing deals to choose from...

Don't miss the best of Auto Express on Google! Make us a preferred source. Click here…