Skoda Octavia Estate vs Vauxhall Astra Sports Tourer: top estates head to head

Anybody who wants a family car, but doesn’t want an SUV, is somewhat limited for choice, yet estate cars offer buyers something different and arguably more practical. Within the sector itself, there are plenty of options available, too, and one that’s been given a bit of a makeover recently is the Vauxhall Astra Sports Tourer.

Blink and you might miss some of the detail changes, but of greater significance is the radical price restructuring that Vauxhall has undertaken to help the Astra ST make headway in terms of sales. In the past, you’d expect to pay a premium of up to £2,000 for an estate over the equivalent hatchback, but for 2026 Vauxhall has introduced price parity between the five-door and the Sports Tourer. What’s more, prices are matched between the hybrid, PHEV and all-electric variants.

Beyond the platform-sharing Peugeot 308, there aren’t many electric or PHEV estates at the Astra’s price point, so for this test we’re pitching the 1.2 Hybrid against the slightly more expensive Skoda Octavia mild hybrid. The Czech machine is one of our favourites, but does it still have the talent to outperform the newly rejuvenated Astra?

Did you know you can sell your car through Auto Express? We’ll help you get a great price and find a great deal on a new car, too.

Vauxhall Astra Sports Tourer

25

The eighth-generation Astra was the first to be developed under the Stellantis umbrella, and it uses a platform that’s shared with the Peugeot 308, among others. As with that model, it comes as either a five-door hatchback or load-lugging estate. 

Used - available now

2020 Audi

A3 Sportback

63,431 milesManualPetrol1.5L

Cash £11,197

View A3 Sportback

2020 Kia

Sportage

63,495 milesManualPetrol1.6L

Cash £11,197

View Sportage

2019 Renault

Kadjar

33,075 milesAutomaticDiesel1.5L

Cash £11,997

View Kadjar

2014 BMW

1 Series

101,168 milesAutomaticPetrol3.0L

Cash £9,995

View 1 Series

Updates in 2026 have seen minor tweaks to the looks and a price restructure, too. The Astra costs from £26,495, and that’s the same for both body styles. Hybrid, PHEV and Electric models are on offer in Griffin, GS and Ultimate specifications.

Tester’s notes

As well as levelling prices between powertrains, Vauxhall slashed the Astra’s RRP when compared with the outgoing car. The PHEV has savings of around £10,000 when compared with its predecessor, while the Astra Electric is around £5,000 less, and that’s before taking the Government’s Electric Car Grant into account.

The Astra qualifies for the £1,500 ECG, so undercuts the Hybrid and PHEV when it’s applied. It’s not the cheapest Astra on offer, though, with the 1.2 petrol manual starting the range at £26,495.

All versions of the Astra come with LED headlights, while top-spec Ultimate models feature advanced Intelli-Lux pixel LED headlights. These include a claimed 51,000 elements that make up the beam pattern, and this adjusts according to the car’s surroundings, dipping for oncoming traffic and cutting out around other road users.

We found them to be very effective, with bright white lighting that illuminated a long distance ahead, although the flickering edge of the beam was a little distracting.

Latest Vauxhall Astra Sports Tourer deals

Skoda Octavia Estate

25

There’s a £985 premium to pay if you want an Octavia Estate instead of the hatchback, while a starting point of £29,725 is around £3,300 more than the Astra’s.  

Engine options aren’t as varied as with the Vauxhall, and neither a PHEV nor full electric model is available. There are 1.5 and 2.0 TSI petrols and 2.0 TDI diesels, but what you get depends on the trim level you choose. The range kicks off with SE Technology, then runs through SE L and SportLine, while a rapid vRS variant completes the line-up.

Tester’s notes

Skoda’s Simply Clever philosophy adds lots of practical touches. The Octavia has an umbrella in the driver’s door, but if you want one on the passenger side (there’s a slot for it), then you need the £255 Family pack, which also adds a third key, double-sided boot floor, storage box and tablet holders for back-seat passengers.

Other standard kit include a ticket holder in the windscreen and an ice scraper/tread depth gauge in the fuel filler, although this is grey plastic and not bright green like it has been in the past.

The Octavia Estate can tow a braked trailer or caravan weighing a maximum of between 1,300kg and 1,600kg, depending on spec and powertrain. The best performer is the 148bhp 2.0 TDI, and in our experience the low-down torque of a diesel engine still makes the most sense when towing. 

The Astra Sports Tourer only manages a 1,200kg maximum when fitted with the petrol engine, 1,100kg in hybrid guise or 1,330kg as a plug-in hybrid. In addition, the Astra Electric isn’t currently rated to tow at all.

Latest Skoda Octavia Estate deals

Head-to-head

25

On the road

Comfort is the primary focus for both cars here, with quiet and refined manners the order of the day. SportLine trim’s sports suspension introduces some bounce to the Octavia when tackling bigger bumps, so we’d recommend a lower-spec car without it. 

The Astra is far more settled, although the hybrid powertrain is more vocal and isn’t as punchy as the Skoda’s set-up, with poorer throttle response overall.

Tech highlights

Digital screens are offered in both cars, with Vauxhall using twin 10-inch displays for the driver and main touchscreen, although the latter is a bit of a stretch to reach.

The Skoda’s bright 13-inch infotainment panel has high-quality graphics and the menu layout is easy to use. If you like to monitor your fuel economy, the Astra’s trip computer isn’t as comprehensive or easy to check as the Octavia’s.

Price and running

AS well as costing less than its rival, the Astra has more kit. A head-up display, heated seats and wheel, adaptive cruise and a powered tailgate are all included, but are either optional or unavailable on the Skoda.

The Astra has lower company-car tax costs and better-value servicing, but the Octavia was more efficient on test – meaning a longer range – and it will hold on to more of its value after three years.

Practicality

Larger overall dimensions help the Octavia Estate to win the space race, although the Astra Sports Tourer has a lower load lip. 

Both cars have levers in the sides of their boots to lower the seat backs remotely, but while the Vauxhall has a powered tailgate, it doesn’t open quite as high as the Skoda’s. If you’re carrying passengers, the Octavia has more space in the back seats.

Safety

The Octavia earned a five-star Euro NCAP rating in 2025, which is better than the four-star score the Astra was awarded in 2022. However, some safety kit, such as adaptive cruise control with traffic jam assist and LED-matrix beam headlights, costs extra.

There’s no such issue with the Astra, which in Ultimate guise features bright Intelli-Lux pixel-LED headlights with clever adaptive beam technology.

Ownership

Standard three-year warranties aren’t anything to write home about, but Skoda offers roadside assistance for the same period. Vauxhall gives 12 months then an additional year with every dealer service. 

Astra owners are offered a four-year service package that’s better value than Skoda’s two-year plan. Vauxhall ranked sixth out of 30 brands in the 2026 Driver Power survey; Skoda finished 20th.

Verdict

Winner: Skoda Octavia Estate

25

Estate cars are all about practicality, and no car in the compact estate class can match the Octavia Estate for sheer user-friendliness. It has more room in the boot than its rival here, but the real clincher is that it also offers good space for passengers.

We’d avoid the SportLine trim and choose an SE L version instead for improved comfort, but there’s not a weak link in the Octavia Touring’s engine range and the Simply Clever features are well thought out and add genuine appeal. And if you need more space, there’s always the larger Skoda Superb.

Runner-up: Vauxhall Astra Sports Tourer

25

Now that the Astra Sports Tourer is the same price as the hatchback, unless you have issues with parking, we can’t see any reason why you’d pick the five-door over the estate.

The other big selling point of the Astra is that it now offers fantastic value for money, much like Skoda used to. While the Sports Tourer doesn’t offer as much space inside as the Octavia Estate, we wouldn’t say the Vauxhall is badly compromised for the money. Unfortunately, the models with the best powertrains (PHEV and Electric) offer less space inside than petrol and Hybrid versions.

Prices and specs

What we would choose

25

Vauxhall Astra Sports Tourer

An 1,100kg towing weight for the Hybrid is modest, but Vauxhall offers a towbar for £605. Metallic paints include Clover Green, which is exclusive to the Sports Tourer; the hatch is offered in Electric Yellow instead.

Skoda Octavia Estate  

Metallics are standard on the Octavia unless you choose Velvet Red, which is £410 (our car’s Dragon Skin yellow is no longer offered). A towbar is £1,115, while the Winter Packs are worthwhile additions, as is a spare wheel.

Looking for your next car? You can now search our nationwide dealer network for a choice of great cars on offer right now with new, used and leasing deals to choose from...

Don't miss the best of Auto Express on Google! Make us a preferred source. Click here…